This project will work with middle school mathematics teachers in San Francisco Unified School District to develop their capacity to conduct professional development for the teachers in their schools. A central goal of this project is to develop models and resources for effective professional development and preparation of professional development leaders in mathematics with special attention to students who are English language learners.
Refining a Model with Tools to Develop Math PD Leaders: An Implementation Study
There is increased demand for K-12 teacher professional development that yields improvements in student learning and achievement. This need is particularly high given widespread adoption of the Common Core State Standards (CCSS) in mathematics which challenges teachers to incorporate mathematical thinking and problem solving into their instruction. The professional development challenge is exacerbated as our nation's demographics continue to shift, increasing the number of English language learners in school districts throughout the U.S. To meet this demand, the educational community must develop large-scale, system-level professional development programs aligned with the CCSS that are scalable and sustainable. The project team from Stanford University will work with middle school mathematics teachers in San Francisco Unified School District to develop their capacity to conduct professional development for the teachers in their schools. A central goal of this project is to develop models and resources for effective professional development and preparation of professional development leaders in mathematics with special attention to students who are English language learners. These models and resources will: provide school districts with the tools to build local capacity and provide sustainable professional development to all middle school mathematics teachers; improve the quality of teaching and, in turn, make important progress toward ensuring that all students in middle school can achieve the mathematical skills and understandings identified in the new standards; and meet the needs of English language learners. In addition, the Stanford team will contribute to the knowledge base in mathematics education, professional development and English language learners.
In previous work, the team developed two interconnected models--the Problem-Solving Cycle (PSC) and the Mathematics Leadership Preparation (MLP) models for preparing professional development leaders. The PSC model consists of a series of interconnected workshops organized around a problem that can be solved using multiple representations and solutions and can be adapted for multiple grade levels. Each cycle focuses on a different math problem. During the first cycle, teachers collaboratively solve the focal math problem and develop plans for teaching it to their students. Teachers then teach the lesson in their classes and the lessons are videotaped. Subsequent workshops focus on participants' classroom experiences teaching the problem. The goals of these workshops are to help teachers learn how to build on student thinking and to explore a variety of instructional practices. They rely heavily on video clips from the PSC lesson to foster productive conversations and situate the conversations in teachers' classroom instruction. The MLP model is designed to prepare Math Leaders to facilitate the PSC. The MLP prepares teachers to lead professional development for their colleagues. These models showed promise of effectiveness in improving middle school mathematics teachers' knowledge and practice, developing math professional development leaders, and improving student achievement. Investigators intend to refine and test the design of the PSC and MLP models and develop resources that can be used by other schools and districts, as well as conduct an evaluation of the work.
Project Videos
2018 STEM for All Video Showcase
Title: A Research-Practice Partnership to Build District Capacity
Presenter(s): Hilda Borko, Janet Carlson, Rebecca Deutscher, & Jim Ryan |
Papers
- Borko, H., Carlson, J., Mangram, C., Anderson, R., Fong, A., Million, S., Mozenter, S. & Villa, A. M. (2017). The role of video-based discussion in model for preparing professional development leaders. International journal of STEM education, 4(1), 1-15.
- Borko, H., Carlson, J., Deutscher, R., Boles, K. L., Delaney, V., Fong, A., Jarry-Shore, M., Malamut, J., Million, S., Mozenter, S., & Villa, A. M. (2021). Learning to Lead: an Approach to Mathematics Teacher Leader Development. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 1-23.
Conference Presentations
- Borko, H. (February 2016). Design-based implementation research in schools: Benefits & challenges. Paper presented at AACTE, Washington, D.C.
- Borko, H & Carlson, J. (April 2016) Design-based implementation research: adapting a professional development leadership model with a school district” Paper presented at AERA in a symposium entitled A Behind-the-Scenes Look at Effective Video-Based Professional Development, Washington, D.C.
- Borko, H. (June 2016). Preparing mathematics teachers to facilitate the problem-solving cycle professional development. Paper presented at the Symposium and Workshop on Video Resources for Mathematics Teacher Development at the Weizmann Institute, Rehovot, Israel.
- Mozenter, S. (February 2017). Video-based discussions: Meeting the multiple demands of PD for content teachers serving English language learners. Presented at National Association for Bilingual Education, Dallas, TX.
- Borko, H. & Villa III, A. M. (March, 2017). Facilitating Video-Based Mathematics Professional Development. Presented at Teacher Development Group Leadership Seminar, Portland, OR.
- Villa III, A. M., & Jarry-Shore, M. (April 2017). Facilitating video-based mathematics professional development. Research symposium at National Council of Teachers of Mathematics Research Conference, San Antonio, TX.
- Carlson, J., Jarry-Shore, M., Barnes, E., & Ellsworth, A. (March 2017). All students & teachers as math learners: A partnership to refine and implement two interconnected models. Presented at Stanford-SFUSD Partnership Annual Meeting, Stanford, CA.
- Borko, H., Carlson, J., Jarry-Shore, M., Barnes, E., & Ellsworth, A. (May 2017). All students & teachers as math learners: A partnership to refine and implement two interconnected models. Presented at Stanford University’s CSET’s Pondering Excellence in Teaching Talk Series, Stanford, CA. (Slides Link)
- Jarry-Shore, M., Fong, A., Dyer, E., Gomez Zaccarelli, F., & Borko, H. (February 2018). Video for equity: Designing video-based discussions of student authority. Presentation at Association of Mathematics Teacher Education, Houston, TX.
- Fong, A., Dyer, E., & Gomez Zaccarelli, F. (February 2018). A shared vision for teacher improvement: Adapting professional development for local context by leveraging district-developed tools. Presentation at Association of Mathematics Teacher Education, Houston, TX.
- Mozenter, S., Gomez Zaccarelli, F., & Ellsworth, A. (February 2018). Video-based discussions in service of student agency, authority, and identity. Presentation at the Association of Teacher Education, Las Vegas, NV.
- Mozenter, S., Ellsworth, A., & Gomez Zaccarelli, F. (March 2018). Using video-based discussions to support content-Area teachers' understanding of student agency, authority, & identity. Presentation at the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education, Baltimore. MD.
- Borko, H. & Villa III, A. M. (March 2018). Building district capacity to address student access & equity: A research-practice partnership to develop teacher leaders. Presentation at the Teacher Development Group Leadership Seminar, Portland, OR.
- Borko, H., Carlson, J., & Treviño, E. (April, 2018). A research-practice partnership to develop district capacity: Learning with & from each other. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, New York, NY.
- Mozenter, S., Borko, H., & Jarry-Shore, M. (June 2018). Complicating the connection: Immigrant-background teachers. Paper presented at Teaching & Teacher Education Special Interest Group of the European Association for Research on Learning and Instruction, Kristiansaand, Norway.
- Treviño, E. Brown, A., Villa III, A.M., & Borko, H. (November 2018). Deconstructing student math content knowledge and groupwork through video-based discussion. Presentation at California Mathematics Council - Northern Section Conference Asilomar, Pacific Grove, CA.
- Jarry-Shore, M. (November 2018). The in-the-moment noticing of the novice mathematics teacher. Paper and presentation at the North American chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, Greenville, SC.
- Villa III, A.M., & Boles, K. (February 2019). Actualizing agency, authority, identity, and access to content in two contrasting cases of mathematical groupwork. Presented at Association of Mathematics Teacher Education, Orlando, FL.
- Borko, H. & Villa III, A.M. (February/March 2019). Building teachers’ capacity to promote students’ access to rigorous and meaningful mathematics through video-based discussions. Presentation at the Teacher Development Group Leadership Seminar, Portland, OR.
- Gomez Zaccarelli, F., Villa III, A.M., Mozenter, S., Boles, K., Deutscher, R., Borko, H., & Carlson, J. (April 2019). How students are oriented toward a mathematical task and their peers: Access to content, agency, authority, and identity. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, Toronto, Canada.
- Mozenter, S., & Borko, H. (April 2019). “Not many people ask me this kind of question.” Three contrasting cases of immigrant-background teachers. Paper presented at the American Educational Research Association, Toronto, Canada.
- Borko, H., Carlson, J. & Deutscher, R. (April 2019). Learning environments to support teacher leaders’ learning to lead video-based discussions. Poster presented in the structured poster session at the American Educational Research Association, Toronto, Canada.
- Villa III, A.M., Boles, K.L., & Borko, H. (November 2019). Teacher leader learning through participation in and facilitation of professional development addressing problems of practice. Paper and presentation at the North American chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education, St. Louis, MO.
- Boles, K. L., Jarry-Shore, M., Muro Villa III, A., Malamut, J., & Borko, H. (2020, June). Building capacity via facilitator agency: Tensions in implementing an adaptive model of professional development. In M. Gresalfi, & I. S. Horn (Eds.), The Interdisciplinarity of the Learning Sciences, 14th International Conference of the Learning Sciences (ICLS) (pp. 2585-2588). Nashville, TN: International Society of the Learning Sciences.
- Jarry-Shore, M., & Allen, T. (2020, December). Noticing Struggle to Support Student Understanding [Conference Presentation]. California Mathematics Council - North Conference, Pacific Grove, CA, United States.